Journalists allowed to attend Zaporizhzhya municipal council, but banned to move around
Zaporizhzhya journalists could attend the regular session of the city council, but they were not allowed to move around the building. Thejournalists were only allowed to get on the balcony of the session hall.
Kateryna Maiboroda, the editor of “Nenachasi”(In bad time), informed the IMI representative in the Zaporizhzhya about this and posted a video from the City Council.
She said that all exits from each floor were blocked with metal gates and secured with scotch tape so that the journalists could not move around.
Mayboroda also said that employees of either the Department of Internal Policy or the mayor's press service are constantly present on the balcony of the session hall together with journalists. Journalists have already been told that during the break they were forbidden to go down to the deputies and speak to them.
According to 061.ua journalist Elmira Shagabudddinova, on February 22, the commission on technogenic and ecological safety and emergencies headed by Mayor Volodymyr Buryak allowed journalists to enter the session only on the third floor, namely on the balcony of the large session hall.
“When we went to the building, we were asked for press cards at two security posts, and in the lobby of the first floor near the wardrobe we were met by the head of the press and information department Diana Semenova. She said that from now on, the journalists had to come together and only at 10.55 accompanied by employees of the department they could go only to the third floor. We were taken there not through the central stairs, but through the side entrance. There we saw that all the entrances to the offices to officials were blocked from the floor and journalists have no right to move anywhere except the balcony, ” the journalist said.
According to Elmira Shagabudddinova, they were told that it was now necessary to come to the session at the fixed time and beinglate were not allowed anymore.
Also, photographers cannot enter the big hall and take photos of deputies, and journalists cannot go down during the break and ask questions to deputies.
IMI lawyer Ali Safarov noted that it could not be unequivocally considered that restrictions of movement of journalists through the City Council premises were an obstacle to the legitimate professional activities of journalists, as they were admitted to the session of the city council.
He reminded that the general norm of Article 25 of the Law of Ukraine “On Information” provided for the possibility of moving around the premises of the subject of power and communication with officials.
However, Safarov added, it was necessary to take into account the lockdown restrictions established by the Cabinet of Ministers "On establishing quarantine and introducing restrictive anti-epidemic measures to prevent the spread of acute respiratory disease COVID-19 caused by coronavirus SARS-CoV-2." In particular, quarantine norms ment limiting the number of people in the premises depending on the floor space of the premises.
“So it cannot be unequivocally considered that restrictions on the movement of journalists through the premises of the city council are an obstacle to the legitimate professional activity of journalists - after all, they are allowed to the meeting, i.e, the session of the city council. However, if a meeting the deputies of the city council is impossible not only during the breaks of the session, but also at other times, if journalists can not be received by officials and officials of the city council, then there will be signs of a criminal offense under Article 171 of the Criminal Code ", - as Ali Safarov said.
We will remind, on February 10 the permanent panel on deputy activity issues, regulations, and prevention of corruption of the Zaporizhia city council suggested to develop the procedure of accreditation of mass media. But the draft decision did not appear on the website of the City Council before the next session on February 24.
As IMI reported, on January 30, more than 20 journalists from Zaporizhzhya addressed a public statement to the governmental authority asking them to intervene and to stop systematic denial of access for the journalists at the Zaporizhia City Council session and meetings of standing deputy commissions.
The journalists said that since the spring of 2020 they have been denied to attend the sessions of the City Council and deputy commissions and so, were unable to fully cover the activities of the city authorities of Zaporizhzhya.
on January 20, the security guards of the Zaporizhzhya City Council did not allow journalists to attend meetings of standing deputy commissions. The guards justified the refusal with quarantine restrictions.
On January 18, Bohdan Vasylenko, editor-in-chief of the Hvozdy portal, was not allowed to attend a meeting of the Zaporizhzhya City Council's standing commission on health care and social protection.
On December 21, 2020, the second extraordinary session of the Zaporizhzhya City Council was held with no journalists present. During the session, the mayor of Zaporizhia, Volodymyr Buryak, refused to submit for vote the issue of the journalists' presence at the session, because they are not representatives of local self-government bodies.
On December 1, 2020, the first session of the Zaporizhzhya City Council was also held without mass media and members of the public due to quarantine restrictions.
On November 4, 2020, two Zaporizhzhzhya journalists were not allowed to attend an extraordinary session of the City Council.
The Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers “ On Quarantine and Restrictive Anti-Epidemic Measures to Prevent the Spread of Acute Respiratory Disease COVID-19 Caused by SARS-CoV-2 Coronavirus ” on December 9, 2020 does not restrict the activities of journalists.