Kyiv’s Pecherskyi District Court has ordered ZN.UA to take down two news stories about NABU serving a suspicion notice to Dmytro Borzykh, former Deputy Prosecutor General for Military Prosecution, and the 10 million hryvnia bail set for him. The court also ordered the outlet to remove several passages from other stories and to publish a retraction. The court confirmed that NABU had indeed notified Borzykh of suspicion, but ruled that publishing his name and details by which he can be identified was a violation. ZN.UA says they will appeal the ruling.
The claim against ZN.UA and its domestic politics editor Inna Vedernikova was filed by Dmytro Borzykh, a deputy prosecutor general for military prosecution turned lawyer. Judge Oleksiy Sokolov has granted some of his demands.
READ MORE
- Censorship through civil lawsuits: the ZN.UA case suggests an emerging threat to journalism
- SLAPP suits against media and journalists: what they are and how to defend press freedom against them
Namely, the court ordered the outlet to fully take down two news stories: one reporting on NABU issuing a suspicion notice to Borzykh, and one concerning the High Anti-Corruption Court’s decision to set a 10 million hryvnia bail for him. It also ordered some passages removed from their other stories, including the investigation “The Hacker Lawyers Case: How NABU Exposed the Parasites”, and to publish a retraction.
Still, the court confirmed in its ruling that on 1 April 2025 NABU did notify Borzykh of suspicion of enabling unauthorised access to the Unified State Register of Court Rulings. However, the court held that reporting his name and other details that could help identify him violated the claimant’s rights. The court also found certain statements in the outlet’s reporting to be false.
Borzykh demanded 500,000 hryvnias in legal fees, including 300,000 hryvnias for legal assistance. For now, the court has ordered a payment of 33,280 hryvnias in his favour: 30,617.60 hryvnias from ZN.UA and 2,662.40 hryvnias from Inna Vedernikova. The court left the question of reimbursing other costs to be tried separately if relevant evidence is submitted.
ZN.UA to appeal the ruling
The ruling was issued on 13 October. However, the defendants’ lawyers only received the full text, dated 16 October, on 16 November — a month later. The lawyers intend to appeal the ruling.
ZN.UA lawyer Yevhen Vorobiov believes the court effectively ignored the newsroom’s evidence and their arguments about the public interest in the case.
“The ruling raises serious doubts about its impartiality and soundness. The court clearly prioritised the claimant’s position and failed to properly assess the evidence and legal arguments presented by the defendants,” he remarked.
In particular, Vorobiov cited a High Anti-Corruption Court ruling that confirmed the journalist’s report that the proceedings were initially classified under Article 368 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. The court did not accept this document as confirmation that the reported information was accurate, since the ruling was only published in the register after the ZN.UA investigation was released.
“The moment a ruling is published has no bearing on whether the information is accurate. The ruling existed and contained the relevant information, confirming that the statement was based on real facts and that the journalist acted in good faith,” Vorobiov explained.
The lawyer also believes the court did not properly take into account the European Court of Human Rights’ case law on freedom of expression, the role of the press, and the protection of journalist sources.
Journalist’s lawyer claims procedure violations
Inna Vedernikova’s lawyer, Roman Vasylniak, has spoken of serious procedural violations, saying that the court had examined the case on the merits in a single hearing without his involvement.
The lawyer was unable to attend the hearing because of an air raid alert that was in effect when it started, and he filed a motion to postpone the review. The court received this request, as it noted in the ruling, but proceeded with the hearing.
“The court deprived the defendant’s side of the opportunity to partake in the examination of evidence, give explanations, put questions to the claimant’s side, or take part in the debates,” Vasylniak stressed.
He believes the court had no grounds to examine the case in such a way, since this was the first time the journalist’s representative had failed to appear. The lawyer also pointed out the way the case had been assigned to a judge, the recusals of two judges, and the doubts previously raised about Judge Sokolov’s impartiality.
The defence pointed out the date of the ruling text completion, as well. Yevhen Vorobiov said he planned to ask the court to correct a potential clerical error. By his preliminary calculations, the court fee for filing an appeal could amount to 40,000 hryvnias. The defence is considering seeking a reduction of this amount or a deferral of payment.
Borzykh vs ZN.UA bears signs of SLAPP
Dmytro Borzykh sued ZN.UA and Inna Vedernikova over 12 news stories reporting on the so-called “hacker lawyers” case.
He demanded that information in “The Hacker Lawyers Case: How NABU Exposed the Parasites” a 22 April 2025 investigation into the activities of the so-called “Borzykh group”, and a series of subsequent news stories be declared false. Borzykh also challenged the outlet’s decision to name him as a suspect before the conviction took legal effect, and demanded reimbursement of almost 500,000 hryvnias in court fees, including 300,000 hryvnias for legal assistance.
According to NABU, the suspects unlawfully accessed classified court rulings, including those in high-profile corruption cases, and passed this information on to their clients. Borzykh has not been convicted in the criminal proceedings.
The Institute of Mass Information and media lawyers had previously pointed out signs that Borzykh’s claim may be a SLAPP suit and may be weaponising the judiciary to pressure journalists through a drawn-out trial and substantial financial demands.
ZN.UA has announced their intention to appeal the Pechersk Court’s ruling and stressed that the case concerned not only their newsroom, but also the right of Ukrainian media to cover criminal proceedings of public interest.
The team cited to Part 4 of Article 296 of the Civil Code of Ukraine, which regulates the use of a suspect or accused’s name in criminal law cases. In the outlet’s view, applying this provision without due regard for the public interest and European standards of freedom of expression may infringe on reporting.
“Applying this provision without due regard for the public interest and European standards of freedom of expression creates a dangerous tool for restricting the work of journalists,” the newsroom said.
ZN.UA warns that such case law could create risks for coverage of other high-profile NABU and SAPO cases, including the operations Midas, Carthage-1, and Carthage-2.